I’ve Survived Through Week 5

Wow. Another presentation down, two papers to go! This week was split pretty evenly between academics and goofing off, though to be fair, this week’s goofing off was pretty productive and impactful. Let’s get going, yeah?

Monday October 10th and Tuesday October 11th: On Monday, Team Supreme met at the Gilchrist to plan our presentation. The assignment was to identify the argument and evidence within a scholarly article, then evaluate the impact and effectiveness of the piece. The subject of the week: Wilde’s The Picture of Dorian Gray and the concept of Decadent Sexualities. The article we were assigned was written by Elizabeth Lorang, called “The Picture of Dorian Gray in Context: Intertextuality and Lippincott’s Monthly Magazine”.

Two quick things…Firstly, my course title is Victorian Literature–Decadence and the Modern, which I write as DecMod in my calendar shorthand. Secondly, no, I’m not yet able to fully articulate the intent of the course. If I were to attempt it now I’d say that we’re examining novels/poems/essays/etc which are concerned with morality, beauty, art, and identity. We’re evaluating them perhaps most in terms of how they break from the literature before 1890 and how they shape the ideals, conventions, and conversations of the turn of the century.

Anyway, Team Supreme (Beatrice, Nicola, Kaitlin, and myself) whipped up a solid presentation and spoke in front of the class on Tuesday. The premise of our article was that Dorian Gray was originally published in a periodical, Lippincott’s Monthly Magazine, and should be read as part of the conversation magazines create within their pages. Lorang calls for an intertextual evaluation of Dorian because she sees connections between the social interests of the time and the rest of the content in the magazine. Published in both Britain and America, the 1890 Lippincott’s were not identical. Lorang focuses on the British version, identifying three additional pieces published in the magazine which she feels situate Dorian in a historical context:

  • “The Cheiromancy of To-Day,” article, Edward Heron-Allen, pp. 102–110. Lippincott’s, July 1890 (British and American version).
  • A Dead Man’s Diary, serial, [Coulson Kernahan], pp. 150–153. Lippincott’s, July 1890 (British version).
  • “The Indissolubility of Marriage,” article, Elizabeth R. Chapman, George T. Bettany, pp. 154–156. Lippincott’s, July 1890 (British version).

If you’re interested in Lorang’s article, here is the basic outline of our powerpoint. We spoke around the quotes, explaining the connections Lorang made and tying it all together.

Historical Context: Intertextuality and Society’s Fascination with the Occult:

  • “Reading Dorian Gray alongside “The Cheiromancy of To-Day,” A Dead Man’s Diary, and “The Indissolubility of Marriage,” three pieces of diverse length, genre, and purpose, illustrates clearly the way in which the individual components of a magazine act as discursive, intertextual counterparts, the ideas in one drawing on, engaging, enriching, and complicating or contradicting ideas in another” (p.22).

A Dead Man’s Diary:

  • A Dead Man’s Diary thus offers a highly theological and moralized ending […] Like A Dead Man’s Diary, The Picture of Dorian Gray provides a “close analysis of human motive and conduct,” often “[overstepping] the line of rectitude”; but unlike A Dead Man’s Diary, interpretations of the conclusion of Dorian Gray have been widely diverse since the novel’s publication in Lippincott’s” (p.29).
  • “In the British edition of the July 1890 Lippincott’s […] The Diary shares several characteristics with Dorian Gray, including the protagonists’ treatment of women and the texts’ employment of the supernatural […] he has brought sexual ruin to others and is in some way responsible for the death of at least one woman” (p.28).

The Indissolubility of Marriage”:

  • “The extent to which Dorian Gray participates in a conversation about marriage rests in the disconnection between the view of marriage Lord Henry professes and what was understood as normative for the middle class readers of Lippincott’s […] His views of marriage, disconcerting to Basil, would most likely have been disconcerting to the middle-class Lippincott’s readership” (p.31).
  • “The Indissolubility of Marriage,” is intentionally framed as a dialogue between two parties” (p.33).
  • Both scenarios, Chapman’s and Bettany’s, comment discursively on Lord Henry’s actions, and Lord Henry’s actions provide examples on which both Chapman and Bettany could ostensibly draw in support of their own arguments […] Reading them together adds to a fuller understanding of the historical conversation” (p.32).

“The Cheiromancy of Today”:

  • “Together, the pieces form a dialogue on the occult and the desire to know one’s soul via outer appearances; this conversation draws on and engages the nineteenth century’s fascination with occultism and the pseudosciences” (p.22).
  • “Throughout Dorian Gray, descriptions of hands are a common component of the narrator’s overall descriptions of individuals […] considers “his own white taper fingers.” […] The soft hands and long fingers, according to Heron-Allen, denote idleness, a fondness for details, carefulness in dress, and a “dignified and irritable” personality. Dorian evinces all of these qualities, and a reading of his hands based on Heron-Allen’s model proves exceptionally accurate” (p.26).
  • “But when Basil Hallward makes an attempt at palmistry, he practices a failed cheirognomy […] Basil does not know what the portrait reflects, but his belief that even one’s hands reflect one’s character is the most explicit intertextual link between Dorian Gray and “The Cheiromancy of To-Day” (p.26-7).

SO, that was quite a bit for the start of the week. Kaitlin and I were much relieved to be done with it all! 20161011_141149

The walk home was lovely, a surprising number of things are still in bloom, considering it’s dropping into the low 40’s, high 30’s at night.

Meg and I went for a walk along the river a few hours later so you can see the Science center, the BBC building, the bridge, and the exhibition center by night!

Honestly, I’m such a huge fan of buildings with color-changing lights.

Wednesday October 12th:

A relatively easy day! Our lecture was on the theorist Farah Mendlesohn and her four-part classification of fantasy. Mendlesohn explores the effectiveness of identifying fantasy texts as portal/quest fantasies, intrusion fantasies, immersion fantasies, or liminal fantasies. Her book, Rhetorics of Fantasy, is a straightforward read and I highly recommend it. I am considering working with her text for a later essay in the course.

My bank card arrived, setting the stage for my indulgences later in the week! First thing I did, however, was buy a £3 ticket to meet Garth Nix, author of The Old Kingdom Collection (Sabriel and Abhorsen being two of the more famous titles). Garth Nix will be in Glasgow on the 24th to talk about his new book Goldenhand, and I will be at Waterstones to hear him!

Thursday October 13th:

Surprisingly enough, DecMod and Fantasy synced up this week, with The Picture of Dorian Gray as a primary text in both courses. In Fantasy, however, we examined the text under the week heading: Gothics. We discussed what it means to be Gothic, how Wilde expresses concern about soul, heart, sexuality, beauty, what elements make the story Fantastic, and so on at length.

I intended to go out with my flatmates afterwards, but we were all too exhausted. Our kitchen time is really nice though, crowded, but domestic.

This is my new ladle, isn’t he perfect?

So the academic part of the week drew to a close with friends and food and wholesome family fun. (No worries family, all my fun is wholesome and above board)

Friday October 14th:

OKAY, the crowning part of Friday was finalizing Christmas plans with Meg.


Doesn’t that look like fun?! We found cheap flights, our accommodation is covered for the most part in Ireland, and we’re looking at AirBnB’s in Brussels 🙂 If you have any connections or suggestions I’d love to hear them. Comment and Follow so I can keep track! Neither of us have been to Brussels before, so since we’re unlikely to be conversant in Flemish by Christmas, I think we need to brush up on our French.


Saturday October 15th and Sunday October 16th:

Last week Dr. Maslen indicated that he was interested in going to the Glasgow Film Theatre to see several movies this weekend and asked if anybody on the course was interested in going along. Plenty of people said that it looked like fun, etc. but apparently I was the only person who actually bought two movie tickets! So, yesterday and today I had Dr. Maslen all to myself, and we saw Kizumonogatori Pt 1&2, and Anthem of the Heart. Both movies were great, I particularly liked Anthem of the Heart because they managed to arrange Beethoven’s Pathetique layered with Arlen’s “Somewhere Over the Rainbow” and it was gorgeous. I’d link the youtube video, but that would spoil the ending of the movie! And of course it was amazing to socialize outside of the classroom. Another advantage to everyone else passing this up was that I could vent a little bit about not yet having a topic for the midterm essay. Dr. Maslen assured me that he hasn’t written the paper he’s presenting in Athens next week, so not to worry that I haven’t started on the one for him due on Halloween! We talked through a few of my ideas and agreed that some were more suitable for longer papers, and that I still need to narrow the focus of one of the stronger ideas.

The GFT was about 1.5miles away, a lovely walk even in the dark last night or in the rain this morning!

On the way to the theatre are some beautiful buildings, and on the way home today was a beautiful pizza! I swear to you, ten minutes before the pictures in the bottom right corner is was POURING rain. My wellies got their day in the sun…well.. you know what I mean, and they were hugely successful. The whole week was successful, actually!


Don’t look for a post next Sunday, I’ll be away next weekend in Skye! I will likely do a post about next week and a separate post for Skye and Garth Nix, so stay tuned. Follow the blog to be notified of updates and leave a comment if you like what you see. ❤

xox C

5 thoughts on “I’ve Survived Through Week 5

  1. Hi Honey I’n still so excited for you. GREAT about getting Dr Maslen to yourself! WHAT LUCK. SO nice to face time . could definitely become addicted to it and expect more and more. Gtg as you know. but sending love and Hugs..xoxoxoxo MOM


  2. Hi Carrianne always fun to read your blog. It’s so well written and laid out. I ‘am so glad your’e enjoying your time in Scotland.

    About the picture of Mr Dorian Gray. I remember seeing the early movie version way back in 1945 0r so . It was filmed in B&W except for the last scene of the painting in full color with the warts and all. To make it more spooky a hanging lamp was swinging back and forth heightening the effect or horror. A link below has the painting but not the effect.

    Keep well and tell us about the Scottish food delights in more detail.

    Love Granpa Jack


    1. Thanks Grandpa! Yes, we were talking about film adaptations in class, particularly about how the color portrait is so impactful at the end of that version. Also, just got your mail, look for a letter headed your way as of Thursday afternoon! ❤


  3. Great update, Carrianne! You’re definitely squeezing out all you can out of your time there. Very proud of you! What are some of the fun expressions you’ve heard from the natives? I’m always fascinated with local slang and the expressions used in the countries where I’ve traveled. I’ve picked up some very colorful ones from English colleagues and I’m curious about what you’re hearing in Scotland. Are you finding it difficult to understand the locales? I’ve found their accent to be particularly challenging. ;^)




    1. 🙂 I’m trying! It’s funny actually, I haven’t heard all that much from natives due to the high international population! I need to do more local dive pub reconnaissance. Most of what I’ve picked up is pretty genial, excepting a rude term or two. I’m definitely interested in expanding that vocabulary!!
      In that same vein, I haven’t had too much trouble understanding anybody, but there is definitely a delay in processing, during which I try to pick out which words were actually words and not rumble.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s